08-27-2012 Tweetchat Compilation

We had 233 updates sent last night from our group. Here’s the questions they dealt with:

Q1: Last 4 years, 621 #UMC churches were planted & 18k YAs trained. Link: http://bit.ly/NyDV2G  Is this “a dying UMC” to you? Why?

  • It’s a sign of a church working smarter. Wonder how many church closures there were in the quadrennium?
  • The numbers are great but how are we keeping and continuing to invest in their life in the future of the church?
  • Decline in membership – is that in long-standing congregations? If so, new plants don’t solve that core issue. Renewal is key.
  • expanding last response. Populations still unchurched, esp. NE. And we have lots of brick and mortar infrastructure. Need mix
  • Are new church starts keeping up with decline/aging congregations? If the UMC dies, “The Church” will continue #resurrection
  • Define “trained.” What’s the purpose of these new churches? Are they in new areas or in addition to established congregations.
  • I think some people equate change with death. I see this as a changing UMC. those embracing change will help the umc thrive
  • is coming up! Big topics tonight! You know the drill. Please begin your response with Q1, Q2 etc and use the hashtag
  • More directly, this looks like a feelgood report, as if someone went out with the purpose of creating awexome stats. #cynic
  • More directly, this looks like a feelgood report, as if someone went out with the purpose of creating awexome stats. #pessimist
  • on a related note, businesses/restaurants relocate to remain vital. many umcs have been in the same physical place too long
  • (My mom answering via phone) How many people are active? We need to know activity of people not numbers to determine vitality
  • Based on numbers the #UMC seems 2 have been in a recession, not a depression. The church can’t die as long as Jesus is center
  • Dying, no. Atrophying, yes! While we grow anew in areas, we need to find a way to renew in others.
  • if we’re racing against death, at this rate i think it might catch-up to us.
  • Last 4 years, 621 #UMC churches were planted & 18k YAs trained. Link: bit.ly/NyDV2G Is this “a dying UMC” to you? Why?
  • No not a dying church. But be aware that a large number of new church plants don’t make it to 5. It’s sort of like an R&D lab
  • No. Cuz # of local churches (new or old) says *nothing* about disciple-making or transforming the world.
  • not dying, but branching. Trads and contemporaries co-existing, but not in unity. Different needs, goals.
  • real question to get @ vitality: what are the people of these local churches doing when they’re not in Sunday services?
  • simplistically: exciting reports! seems like ministry thrives when fertile ground is tended
  • New growth is the future, but we aren’t doing as much as we can or need to. #churchplanting #dreamumc
  • Our 100+ year old church added lift last year, to make fellowship hall accessible but isn’t outside our doors much.

Q2: Despite Plan UMC’s failure at #gc2012, bishops are still using the CTA rec’ed vital stats. Are these helpful indicators? Why?

  • as long as they’re used as a conversation starter, there’s no problem with the metrics.
  • it’s good to start some where. but agree that numbers alone can’t tell a ministry story.
  • #metrics We gave out 96 bottles of water at our town’s Old Home Day parade on Saturday and we put out 40 chairs for community.
  • I haven’t read the stats Information is important but vision/discernment should be at heart of this movement Listen for Spirit.
  • also, tracking the numbers can give a measurable benchmark for change. Anyone have a way to measure disciple making?
  • Can be helpful indicators, but vital stats and numbers in general need to be a minor piece of the plan, not the major part.
  • cont. sometimes following Christ leads to decline in numbers.
  • cont’d(No): Let’s ask how, not how many. Depth & impact – not shallow bean-counting. Qualitative, not quantitative metrics.
  • Did numbers tell us anything we didn’t already know? #fearreigns
  • I think numbers can tell a great story, how they change, how they shift. however the qualitative must be joined by quantitative
  • it’s a start – but the numbers should build to something bigger and more informative
  • That depends on how stats are used. Helpful if they are a motivation to change; not helpful if they lead to fear/entrenchment
  • UMC currently runs on a business model, but what works on a factory floor doesn’t work in a sanctuary. #6sigma4jesus
  • Despite Plan UMC’s failure at #gc2012, bishops are still using the CTA rec’ed vital stats. Are these helpful indicators? Why?
  • I actually blogged about this when doing the Sync blog with @umjeremy prior to GC. signsunseen.com/?p=54
  • I think there are ways to judge quality of the fruits instead of the entire yield.
  • I totally agree with @KVG_DC. There is a place for stats, but that isn’t the whole story. shouldn’t be slaves to data.
  • if not numbers what statistics/signs do we tract to indicate discipleship?
  • If we actually cared about transforming the world, wouldn’t we ask people *outside* the church how we’re doing?
  • In a denom with problems with bureaucracy dominating spirit and daring, I suspect demanding the CTA stats is a problem.
  • I’ve long felt that while outcome metrics aren’t inherently bad. The CTA dashboards aren’t measuring what we need to know.
  • No…look at #neumc our churches are so small but look at the amazing ministries coming out of New England #shoutout
  • Numbers do mean a lot, but what is more important is what you do with those numbers. #discipleship
  • No. Pew sitters aren’t same as disciples. Internally measured #s don’t speak to transforming world.
  • So far as I know annual state generated almost no feedback here- maybe the anointed got it. I don’t know that it was read.
  • Studying “The External Church.” some people are so internally-focused, they need the “proof” we’re bleeding to be motivated.
  • yes, but only as input. #s offer and indication of what ur facing/working with
  • They are and help Bishops/DSs see problem areas and growth sooner for further consideration. They are a good tool.
  • Little stories of transformation can’t be easily benchmarked.
  • Attendance, Giving, Outreach and other things are tracked. Together they can point to discipleship or no.
  • They measure a lot more than “pew sitters.” See for yourself! northalabamaumc.org/weeklyreport.a…

Q3: So of course the big one- what should indicate growth or vitality in the #UMC? How do we eval discipleship & transformation?

  • Programs like HCI can help: ctcumc.org/pages/detail/1…
  • The bible says we are to sow seeds, to be seeds, to tend the soil; but we are to leave growth to God. bad metrics.
  • What were the original marks of discipleship? I think Mt Pisgah UMC could offer a helpful way: seedbed.com/feed/dinesh-an…
  • #America One way to get results we want is to remove Sunday morning conflicts of child sports, boy scouts, other activities
  • We need to be doing what we were called to do, to make disciples. Discipleship is within each heart Cannot be measured.
  • There will always be a tension between measurements and making disciples. #UMC needs members/donors supporting budgets. cont.
  • We had our Spirit Study last night on the front steps and someone from the town joined us. Again, not sure how that fits.
  • Go back to our mission statement: are disciples being made? is the world being transformed? #mydashboard
  • IMO the answers have 2 B relational not numerical. That means DSs R really going 2 have 2 work 2 know pastors & churches.
  • Jesus fed 5,000 hungry peeps–none became disciples. Is feeding the hungry enough? #whoevergivesacupofcoldwater
  • No one expects to answer this question in a tweet chat, but this cuts to the heart of what we’re about: being a faithful #umc !
  • Could we somehow measure the literal fruits? Personal conversations with members? Impression neighbors have of church?
  • Disciples can be made in worship, but are maintained through small group ministry and mission work.
  • disciples create more disciples, which seems as though measurable growth would result.
  • Energy in our congregations. People spiritually fed who want to serve. I think %ages in ministries might speak > #s.
  • from a business marketing perspective, is the “Jesus” brand gaining market share and building influence online and IRL?
  • I also agree with people talking about small groups. They are a huge indication of strong discipleship!
  • I still think # but I am in the minority, # can measure everything from missions to small groups
  • If small groups don’t work we could always get bitten by venomous snakes and if God heals us, it’s because we’re vital
  • Local congregations need to be encouraged to set goals, with the help of DSs have accountability to reach them.
  • Local congregations set their own goals and build outcomes that lead to those goals. Nonprofits do this for reporting and eval
  • provide local congregations with more avenues to share their stories. So the general church can actually know what’s going on
  • So of course the big one- what should indicate growth or vitality in the #UMC? How do we eval discipleship & transformation?
  • Stats on attendance, giving, etc. are good for the denomination. It’s up to individual churches to evaluate their quality.
  • Using small groups worked for John Wesley, I don’t see why it can’t work now
  • Worship attendence as related to small group attendence and participation in mission work (local and away).
  • The idea of “one metric to rule them all” assumes metrics are about comparing congregations in radically different contexts 1/2 Metrics that measure vitality in ways that help cong. are not comparative but used to estab goals and steps to achieve them 2/2

Join us for our next Tweetchat on September 10th, 2012 @ 9pm Eastern (6pm Pacific)

Posted in Conversations

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

DreamUMC is a grassroots effort to effect change in the United Methodist Church. We have bi-weekly twitter-based conversations where all UMC folks are invited to join and let their voice be heard. Click here to learn more.

The movement began after General Conference 2012 and is amplifying and organizing in ways beyond conversation. Click here to learn more.